select search filters
briefings
roundups & rapid reactions
Fiona fox's blog

expert reaction to the UK-EU Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) agreement*

Scientists respond to the UK-EU Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) Agreement that sets out new arrangements for trade in food, agricultural goods, animals and plants.

Prof Denis Murphy, Emeritus Professor of Biotechnology, University of South Wales, said:

“To support innovation and growth in food and farming, England’s precision breeding framework will remain in place until July 2028, when the EU’s new genomic technique framework for plants takes effect. Businesses will be able to continue marketing precision bred products under England’s regulatory framework until October 2029. The arrangements apply to precision bred plants and to food and feed produced from them.”

Dr Khaoula Belhaj-Fragnière, Director, Innovation, Trade and Market Access, International Seed Federation (ISF), said:

“The UK has moved in the right direction by updating its framework to reflect advances in plant breeding, but it can go further by working with the EU to promote regulatory interoperability and provide greater predictability for innovators seeking to bring new products to market.

“When regulations are fragmented, there is a real cost. When identical products are treated differently across markets, developers face uncertainty, leading to unnecessary delays and rising costs. Let’s not ask farmers and consumers to wait longer for much-needed innovation to reach their fields and plates. Instead, let’s act so innovation can move efficiently across borders and expand farmers’ access to solutions that improve productivity and nutrition, and feed a growing population sustainably.”

Katrina Hayter, CEO of Niab, said: 

“Niab welcomes the agreement to strengthen UK–EU cooperation and reduce barriers to trade in agricultural products. This closer alignment gives breeders in England a period of continuity under the existing framework. However, it is essential that these benefits are achieved without restricting scientific innovation or delaying the development and commercialisation of improved crop varieties.

“England’s precision breeding legislation has created an important framework for translating advances in plant genetics and gene editing into practical agricultural applications. The advances made to date  offer opportunities to develop crops with improved resistance to pests and diseases, greater resilience to environmental stresses and more efficient use of resources. At Niab, our work spans the pathway from  crop improvement through to field evaluation and pre-commercial development.

“The EU’s adoption of new genomic techniques legislation is a welcome development towards a more proportionate, science-based regulatory approach.  However, the differences between the two frameworks, together with the timing of their implementation, raise important questions about the continuity of UK research, field trials, regulatory approvals and commercial development.

“Predictable, proportionate and evidence-based regulation is essential for sustaining investment, encouraging innovation and ensuring that advances in plant science deliver tangible benefits for growers, consumers, food security and environmental sustainability across both the UK and Europe.”

Prof Gideon Henderson, University of Oxford and former CSA to Defra, said:

“It is good for English science, and for the English biotech sector, that the use of gene editing to develop improved plant varieties continues.  There are many potential benefits from the use of gene editing to safely and precisely develop crops with useful traits, such as resilience to climate variables, higher yields, or lower concentrations of allergens.  

“The post-Brexit Genetic Technologies (Precision Breeding) Act of 2023 allowed application of gene editing for plants and the sale of products in the English market, freeing agri- and bio-tech companies to produce a wide range of new products.  Similar EU legislation is now being developed and will come into place in 2028.  Stalling progress in England until this date would have been a significant retrogressive step with risk of driving innovative companies overseas.  

“Today’s agreement to keep England’s precision breeding framework in place until the EU regulation catches up is good news.”

Prof Emily Lydgate, Professor of Environmental Law, and Co-Director of the UKTPO at the University of Sussex, said:

“Having only certain areas – food law and the Emissions Trading Scheme – inside the EU Single Market is a new situation for the UK Government, very different from both EU membership and its post-Brexit EU relationship as governed by the TCA. While the challenges of dynamic alignment post-Brexit are new to the UK as a whole, they are not completely exotic: Northern Ireland has an established track record of dynamic EU alignment. Many of the same challenges it has faced will now face the UK as a whole. The UK can save considerable time and effort by applying these lessons.”

Prof Nick Talbot FRS, Executive Director of The Sainsbury Laboratory, said:

“Harmonisation of the regulations regarding precision bred crops is clearly critical if these products are going to reach the largest number of consumers across Europe. 

“Ensuring a clear path forward across the EU was therefore always going to be vital for businesses in the UK developing these advanced technologies, based on discoveries from leading plant scientists in our institutes and universities. 

“The benefits of precision bred crops are enormous. From enhanced nutrient and fibre content to eliminating the use of pesticides in future, they have the capacity to provide new  innovation in agriculture across the continent.

“We hope that the government will negotiate to enable UK scientists to be consulted on the new EU regulations as they are finalised, given their experience in developing the UK rules. In that way we can help to ensure that an evidence-based scientifically rigorous and stable regulatory framework is developed in the  European Union. Having UK experts in the room will be important.”

Prof Martin Warren, Quadram Institute research group leader, said:

“We welcome the news that the UK has secured the retention of its approach to precision breeding in the short-term but note that we will align with the EU’s NGT approach from 2029.

“Precision breeding offers enormous potential to develop more sustainable, resilient and nutritious crops, helping us produce food with a lower environmental footprint while improving its nutrient density and contribution to human health. At a time when we urgently need to transform how we produce food, it is essential that regulation enables rather than constrains responsible innovation.

Prof Guy Poppy, PVC Research and Innovation, University of Bristol, said:

“This is excellent news for UK producers, consumers and farmers. Since leaving the UK, our food exports have dropped, our food security become less resilient and our food no safer. This agreement removes barriers which didn’t previously exist and will enhance our ability to be aware of food safety issues by sharing intelligence and insight.

“Novel foods and novel technologies need regulation which is evidence based and UK scientists can play an important part in negotiations and expert advice which will ultimately allow new and novel foods which lead to a healthier planet and healthier people.”

Prof Cristóbal Uauy, Director of the John Innes Centre, said:

“Genetic technologies are an important tool to support the development of crops and plants that are sustainable for the environment, nutritious for the public, and resilient to climate change.

“Aligning with the EU market will bring our science to a greater number of people and this clearer trajectory is essential for helping businesses maintain momentum, plan research, build partnerships and attract investment. 

“With Europe still defining the details of how to regulate these new genetic technologies, we welcome the announced ‘exception period’ allowing products in the UK pipeline to remain on the UK market while they seek approval under the EU legislative framework.”

 

Declared interests

Guy Poppy “was CSA at FSA from 2014-2020 and BBSRC exec chair 2023-2024”

Martin Warren: “No interests to declare”

Katrina Hayter: “no interests to declare”

Denis Murphy: “None”

Khaoula Belhaj-Fragnière: “The ISF represents 96% of the international private seed trade including members in all four corners of the globe. It also has official observer status in intergovernmental and international organisations and assists in developing government policy and business strategy.  I also previously worked at the Sainsbury Laboratory.”

Emily Lydgate: “none”

Cristóbal Uauy “has funding for field trials of precision bred wheat funded by Defra’s Farming Innovation Programme”

Nick Talbot:

 

Organisation/Entity

Nature of interest

Role /

Relationship

Relevant to Charity activities

Date declared

1.

The Sainsbury

Laboratory

 

Paid

Executive Director

Yes

16/11/2026

2.

Gatsby Charitable Foundation 

Paid

Plant

Science

Advisor

No

16/11/2026

3.

John Innes Council 

Unpaid

Board

Observer

No

16/11/2026

4.

The Two Blades

Foundation 

 

Unpaid

Board

Observer 

No

16/11/2026

5.

Norwich Bioscience

Institutes Partnership

Board

 

Unpaid

Chair

No

16/11/2026

6.

Plant Bioscience Limited Technology Ltd.

 

Unpaid

Director

No

16/11/2026

7.

Anglian Innovation

Partnership LLP Board

 

Unpaid

 

Director

No

16/11/2026

8.

Plant Science Innovations Ltd.

Unpaid

Director

No

16/11/2026

“The Sainsbury Laboratory (TSL) is a registered charity, number 1065510, but holds equity in companies created from its research activities including RessurectBio, BioPotatoes and Norfolk Plant Science. TSL collaborates with the following agricultural biotechnology companies in plant immunity research Rijk Zwaan, Bejo, Limagrain, BASF, Bayer and Tropic Biosciences.”

*https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6b0040fcf31a4724a476570f/UK_EU_Summit_2026_Explainer_SPS.docx__2_.pdf

in this section

filter RoundUps by year

search by tag