select search filters
briefings
roundups & rapid reactions
Fiona fox's blog

Why the future of news isn’t all bad

This is a guest blog post by Helen Jamison, Global Coordinator at the SMC

If you’ve been paying attention to recent headlines about the challenging media climate, you could be forgiven for thinking the future of mainstream news is extremely dire. Hardly a day goes by without stories of job losses, falling public trust, or AI’s rapid advance into the newsroom. For news junkies like me who care about the critical role of journalism, it’s hard not to feel depressed.

But is this the whole story? What if, when you read between the lines, there are also some – dare I say it – positives emerging in these bleak times? The challenges facing journalism are serious and must be treated as such. But if we let the doom-laden narrative take hold without questioning it, might we risk it becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy?

A list I wrote on a train

On a recent (long) train journey home from yet another event telling us just how bad things are, I decided to write a list of the positive things I’d also heard that day. It was an attempt to gain some perspective and not feel overwhelmed. What surprised me was how long that list was.

Trust remains relatively high for mainstream news brands, which are showing some resilience. Countries with public broadcasters are tending to fare best. Many audiences still have a traditional sense of what news is: something made by journalists and published by news outlets. Few think that anything they see on social media counts as news just because it is new, and an even smaller proportion get their news exclusively from content creators and influencers.

Equally encouraging is that audiences don’t want artificial debates and rows. They generally want balanced views, accuracy, transparency, and impartiality. Explainers and long-form content like podcasts are popular because people want to understand things, and, contrary to current narratives, they are able to pay attention for more than a nanosecond. There are reasons to believe future models of journalism will favour high-quality reporting that people are willing to pay for, rather than clicks and reach. 

Media organisations also seem to be working together more than ever. There is more innovation, training, and strategic thinking going into how they tackle the challenges as an industry, and approaches are becoming more nuanced and proactive. Some outlets are prioritising long-term plans for tomorrow rather than quick fixes today.

And while old-school hacks might despair at the rise of influencers, the reasons for their popularity offer hope: audiences say they are easy to understand, relatable, and accessible. In a world dominated by AI algorithms and aggregators, original reporting, human interest, and relationships with audiences might actually win out. The high levels of public trust in local news given the current climate are a case in point.

A crisis or a shake-up?

There is no question that the problems facing journalism are very real, and losing the order we are used to can be frightening. But perhaps the changes – no matter how unsettling – are better characterised as an upheaval we can overcome. Writer Naomi Alderman argues that we are living through the third information crisis, after writing and printing. Both earlier crises brought conflict and radical change, but we came through them.

The current era feels particularly tough because it is weakening trust in the institutions and authoritative voices that have guarded the truth since the printing press. But what if this way of managing information was the exception rather than the rule, and the print era was more of a parenthesis than a one-way evolution, as media scholar Jeff Jarvis suggests? None of this means everything will be fine, but it suggests we might be in the messy emergence of something we have dealt with before. 

Maybe the public will be better served by many voices than by a few tablets of stone. Maybe the authenticity of individuals talking directly to audiences is a good thing. Organisations might have to drop the single, faceless key messages that protect their reputation but do nothing for public understanding; they won’t wash any more. They’ll need to embrace open dialogue and let go of some control if they want to stay relevant.

And while it’s worrying that news websites are rapidly losing traffic from search engines like Google, is it so bad that Google no longer decides which sites we see? Could some forms of AI curation eventually be more impartial and democratic? Perhaps, but only if we understand how they work and whose interests they serve. The hard part is protecting what matters most. 

What this means for science communication

As we like to say at the Science Media Centre, a crisis is an opportunity as well as a threat, and this one is no exception: there is good news for science. First, people are still interested in it, and it ranks among the top five interests across age groups. It enjoys high levels of public trust and is one of the few subjects that can bring people together, because it gives society common experiences and a shared curiosity. If audiences want stories that are interesting, trustworthy, and widely shared, news outlets have every reason to report more science, not less. And despite the cuts, a recent science journalism conference was packed with smart, thoughtful people who want to make things better.

Second, science offers something this moment badly needs: evidence. We are surrounded by fake experts, fake press releases, and endless opinion. In that noise, tested facts are scarce. Science is a way of finding out what is true, and of saying so when we aren’t sure. That has never been more valuable, and I hope the news leans into it. The flood of fake online experts might even revive the good old practice of journalists phoning people directly for comment, something that has perhaps fallen away since Covid.

The third point is for those of us who communicate on behalf of institutions. Universities, research bodies, governments, and charities have long relied on a single, careful, corporate voice, always on message. Maybe these changes could bring an end to those days. Losing authority isn’t the same as losing expertise. It means expertise must be communicated differently. Content creators are popular for a reason, and a faceless line to take can’t compete.

So the advice is simple. Let researchers speak as themselves. Tell a story. Say what we know, what we don’t, and why it matters. Accept that we will lose some control. Institutions that do this will have a better chance of earning trust. Those that don’t risk looking out of date. None of this means lowering standards. The best science communication has always been accurate, balanced, and honest about the evidence. That’s what makes a voice worth listening to.

The values of accuracy, verification, independence, and a commitment to public interest don’t belong to any one business model, and the decline of traditional institutions isn’t the same as the decline of those values. They can survive, and perhaps even flourish, in a very different media landscape if we make sure they do. After all, hope is a verb. 

This blog contains the thoughts of the author rather than representing the work or policy of the Science Media Centre.

in this section

filter Blog by year

search by tag